2023
All Conference
Goalies: Maddie Burgan (NEDubois), Alli Stearns (Vincennes Rivet)
Emma Johnson (NEDubois), Ady Kiefer (NEDubois), Brooklyn Kiefer (NEDubois), Kelli Merkel (NEDubois), Landyn Rasche (NEDubois), Daisee Cardinal (North Knox), Briley Utt (North Knox), Delaney Foley (South Knox), Meg Phegley (South Knox), Ava Benson (Vincennes Rivet), Kevi Black (Vincennes Rivet), Emma Stine (Vincennes Rivet), Lissa Willis (Vincennes Rivet), Angela Santiago (Washington Catholic), Celeste Santiago (Washington Catholic), Rosie Serrano (Washington Catholic)
2022
All Conference
Goalies: Maddie Burgan (NEDubois), Addie Talbert (Washington Catholic)
Players: Aubrey Hostetter (NEDubois), Kelli Merkel (NEDubois), Landyn Rasche (NEDubois), Elizabeth Schepers (NEDubois), Emma Elkins (North Knox), Lucy Sheren (North Knox), Morgan Alderton (South Knox), Kenzie Johnson (South Knox), Taylor Medlan (South Knox), Nya Dame (Vincennes Rivet), Makenzie Willis (Vincennes Rivet), Mya Cline (Washington Catholic), Ella Grissom (Washington Catholic), Bryanna Hunter (Washington Catholic)
2021
All Conference
Lexi Freyberger (ND), Brooklyn Kiefer (ND), Kelli Merkel (ND), Landyn Rasche (ND), Emma Elkins (NK), Lanie Vestal (NK), Morgan Alderton (SK). Jordyn Derouin (SK), McKenzie Johnson (SK), Katie Daugherty (VR), Mya Cline (WC), Alyssa Davison (WC), Ella Grissom (WC) Goalies Alexis Hawkins (ND), Jayda Millspaugh (SK)
2020
All Conference
Lexi Freyberger (ND), Landyn Rasche (ND), Lucy Sheren (NK), Jordyn Derouin (SK), Taylor Medlen (SK), Reagan Nowaskie (SK), Morgan Alderton (VR), Maggie Earley (VR), Katie Daugherty (VR), Katherine Herman (VR), Mya Cline (WC), Claire Fox (WC), Ella Grissom (WC) Goalies Riley Petro (NK), Ellie Fausnaug (SK)
2019
All Conference
Lexi Fryberger (ND), Aubrey Hostetter (ND), Emma Stanczak (NK), Jordyn Derouin (SK), Coral Hardig (SK), Maggie Earley (VR), Caroline Herman (VR), Kennedy Johnson (VR), Abby Niehaus (VR), Tia Tolbert (VR), Ally Cline (WC), Claire Fox (WC), Eline Rutledal (WC), Riley Petro (NK), Jayda Millspaugh (VR)
2018