2024
All-Conference:
Kyle Graber (BR/JR{1}), Kierson Lengacher (BR/SO{1}), Levi Lester (BR/JR{1}), Isaac Madison (BR/SR {2}), Xavier Meiring (BR/JR{3}), Brody Swartzentruber (BR/SR{1}), Daniel Underwood (BR/SO{1}), Joe Graber (L/JR{1}), Cooper Van Hoy (L/FR{1}), Koen Waggner (L/SR{3}), Wade Walton (L/SR{1}), Carson Beck (NED/SO{1}), Elijah Buechler
(NED/JR{1}), Drew Schroering (NED/SR{1})
{} = number of all-conference tennis selections
2023
All-Conference:
Isaac Waggner (L/SR {3}), Brandon Bledsoe (L/SR {2}), Koen Waggner (L/JR {2}), Drew Walker (L/SR {2}), Leighton Jeffers (L/SR {3}), Donnie Miller (BR/SR {3}), Xavier Meiring (BR/SO {2}), Ethan Stoll(BR/JR {2}), Isaac Madison (BR/JR {1}), Aiden Buechler (NED/SR {3}), Noah Hayden (SK/SR {1}), Gavin Bigham (WM/SR {2})
{} = number of all-conference tennis selections
2022
All-Conference:
Isaac Waggner (L/JR {2}), Brandon Bledsoe (L/JR {1}), Koen Waggner (L/SO {1}), Peyton Bledsoe (L/SR {2}), Drew Walker (L/JR {1}), Leighton Jeffers (L/JR {2}), Reis Whitney (L/JR {1}), Aiden Buechler (NED/JR {2}), Ty Kalb (NED/SR {1}), Brayden Beck (NED/SR {1}), Donnie Miller (BR/JR {2}), Ethan Stoll(BR/JR {1}), Xavier Meiring (BR/FR {1}), Nathan Robbins (SK/SR {2}), Gavin Bigham (WM/JR {1})
{} = number of all-conference selections
2021
All-Conference:
Kayden Graber (BR/SR {4}), Aden Thewes (NED/SR {1}), Luke Nonte (L/SR {3}), Isaac Waggner (L/SO {1}), Leighton Jeffers (L/SO {1}), Hagen Knepp (BR/SR {3}), Aiden Buechler (NED/SO {1}), Donnie Miller (BR/SO {1}), Nathan Robbins (SK/JR {1}), Rory Tippery (L/SR {1})
{} = number of all-conference selections
2020
All-Conference:
Jordan Wildman (L/SR), Kayden Graber (BR/JR), Jalen Wildman (L/SR), Aden Thewes (NED/JR), Tommy Kidwell (BR/SR), Brycen Graber (BR/SR), Luke Nonte (L/JR), Bryant Eckerle (L/SR), Peyton Bledsoe (L/SO), Ross Mehringer (NED/SR), Hagen Knepp (BR/JR)