2020
All-Conference:
Jordan Wildman (L/SR), Kayden Graber (BR/JR), Jalen Wildman (L/SR), Aden Thewes (NED/JR), Tommy Kidwell (BR/SR), Brycen Graber (BR/SR), Luke Nonte (L/JR), Bryant Eckerle (L/SR), Peyton Bledsoe (L/SO), Ross Mehringer (NED/SR), Hagen Knepp (BR/JR)
2019
All-Conference:
Nathan Hunt (BR/SR), Logan Graber (BR/JR)/Hagen Knepp (BR/SO), Jalen Wildman (L/JR), Reece Bauer (NED/SR), Jordan Wildman (L/JR), Kayden Graber (BR/SO), Tommy Kidwell (BR/JR)/Aaron Wagler (BR/SO), Sebastian Toy (L/SR)/Luke Nonte (L/SO), Ethan Ziegler (NED/SR)/Luke Harder (NED/SR)
2018
All-Conference:
Reece Bauer (NED), Jalen Wildman (LHS), Brycen Graber (B-R), Colten Mouzin (VR), Sheldan Christmas / Jordan Wildman (LHS), Ethan Ziegler (NED), Gage Wilson / Isaac Wagler (B-R), Kayden Graber (B-R)